Crating multiple dogs successfully involves careful planning, positive reinforcement, and understanding each dog's individual needs and temperament. While having a dedicated crate for each dog is often the ideal scenario, it is possible to manage with fewer crates under specific conditions.
The Optimal Approach: Individual Crates
For the majority of multi-dog households, providing each dog with their own crate is the most recommended and stress-free solution. This ensures each dog has a personal, secure space they can retreat to, minimizing potential conflicts or stress. For example, if you have two dogs, it is best to have two separate crates, allowing each canine companion their own den.
Benefits of Individual Crates:
- Personal Space: Each dog has their own sanctuary, reducing stress and promoting security.
- Safety: Prevents potential squabbles over space, food, or toys, especially when unsupervised.
- Easier Training: Dogs can learn at their own pace without distraction from housemates.
- Hygiene: Easier to keep clean and manage accidents if they occur.
- Flexibility: Allows for separate feeding, quiet time, or managing different routines.
The Alternative: Sharing Crates
In situations where space is limited or for highly compatible dogs, you can sometimes get away with using fewer crates than the number of dogs you have, perhaps one less, much like a game of musical chairs where not every participant has a dedicated seat. This might involve two compatible dogs sharing a single, appropriately sized crate, or rotating crate use among dogs.
Important Considerations for Shared Crating:
- Temperament Compatibility: This approach is only suitable for dogs with a proven track record of getting along extremely well, with no history of aggression, resource guarding, or significant dominance issues, especially in confined spaces.
- Crate Size: If sharing a crate, it must be large enough for all occupants to stand up, turn around, and lie down comfortably without touching each other. A general rule of thumb is that it should be 1.5 times the size recommended for the largest dog if two dogs are sharing.
- Duration: Shared crating should generally be reserved for shorter durations and under close supervision.
- Stress Monitoring: Closely observe all dogs for any signs of stress, anxiety, or discomfort, such as panting, yawning, lip-licking, or stiffness.
Essential Tools for Multi-Dog Crate Training
Regardless of whether you choose individual or shared crating, positive reinforcement is crucial for success.
- High-Value Treats: Always have a nice selection of different, high-value treats readily available. These could include small pieces of cooked chicken, cheese, or specialized training treats. Variety helps keep dogs engaged.
- Clicker: A clicker is an invaluable tool for marking the exact moment your dog performs the desired behavior, creating a clear communication channel and speeding up the learning process.
- Comfort Items: Soft bedding, safe chew toys, and water bowls (if appropriate for the duration) can make the crate more inviting.
Step-by-Step Training Guide
Effective crate training for multiple dogs often involves a combination of individual and group efforts:
-
Individual Acclimation First:
- Introduce each dog to their own crate (even if they will eventually share).
- Make it a positive experience with treats and praise, never as punishment.
- Allow them to explore the crate with the door open, dropping treats inside.
- Practice short durations with the door closed, gradually increasing the time.
-
Introducing Multiple Crates (If Individual Setup):
- Place crates in a common area but far enough apart to give each dog personal space.
- Practice crating each dog simultaneously, rewarding calm behavior.
- Initially, ensure dogs cannot see each other in their crates if they get overly excited or anxious.
-
Pairing/Group Crate Training (If Sharing):
- Only attempt this after individual dogs are comfortable being crated alone.
- Start by letting highly compatible dogs enter a large shared crate together, with the door open.
- Reward heavily for calm, relaxed behavior inside.
- Gradually close the door for very short periods, always observing for any tension.
- Never force dogs to share if they show any signs of discomfort or aggression.
-
Making Crates Enjoyable:
- Feed meals inside crates with the doors open, then gradually closed.
- Provide enrichment toys like KONGs filled with frozen peanut butter or other safe treats.
- Consistently use a happy, upbeat tone when directing them to their crates.
Key Factors for Success
- Consistency: Use crates regularly for short periods, even when not strictly necessary.
- Positive Association: Never use the crate as a punishment. It should always be a safe, rewarding space.
- Appropriate Placement: Place crates in a quiet, low-traffic area where dogs still feel part of the family but can relax.
- Health and Wellness: Ensure all dogs have relieved themselves before crating, especially for longer durations.
- Professional Guidance: If you encounter challenges, consult with a certified professional dog trainer or veterinary behaviorist. You can find resources on reputable sites like the Association of Professional Dog Trainers or the Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers.
Comparison: Individual vs. Shared Crates
| Feature | Individual Crates | Shared Crate (for multiple dogs) |
|---|---|---|
| Safety | High (prevents conflict) | Moderate to Low (requires high compatibility, supervision) |
| Comfort | Each dog has personal space | Can be cramped if not appropriately sized; less personal space |
| Training Ease | Easier, fewer distractions | More complex, requires excellent social skills between dogs |
| Space Required | More floor space needed for multiple units | Less floor space overall, but needs one very large crate |
| Ideal For | All multi-dog households, especially new or anxious dogs | Highly compatible, bonded dogs for short periods and under supervision |
By understanding these principles and applying positive, consistent training methods, you can effectively and humanely crate multiple dogs, ensuring their safety and well-being.
